The Temptations of a Sanctified Heart (rewritten)

At this point, our goal is to give a broad but careful overview of temptation — especially the kind experienced by someone whose heart is genuinely given to God. We’re talking about people who live in assurance, whose lives can rightly be described as sanctified. Even hearts like these are not exempt from temptation, and understanding how temptation works is essential to living faithfully.

At its core, temptation begins when something is presented to the mind — an object, an idea, or a situation — that has the potential to stir the desires or move the will in a wrong direction. That “wrong direction” can take two different forms. Sometimes the action temptation urges is simply wrong. Other times, the action is acceptable in itself but becomes wrong because it is carried too far. Either way, when temptation moves beyond thought and gains the consent of desire or will — prompting action when there should be none, or excessive action where restraint is required — sin is always the result. 

Seen from this perspective, temptation shows up in two main ways.

First: Temptations to What is Inherently Wrong

In some cases, temptation aims to bring into existence feelings or impulses that are wrong simply by existing. These are desires that have no rightful place under any circumstances and should never be allowed. Often, such temptations are carefully tailored — whether by circumstances or by Satanic influence — to provoke exactly that forbidden reaction. If the feeling arises at all, even slightly, it is already sin.

The temptations faced by Jesus help illustrate this clearly. When the kingdoms and riches of the world were presented to him, the invitation was plainly meant to stir selfish ambition. Yet Christians generally agree that the temptation never moved beyond thought. It did not awaken desire or willful consent. It was recognized — and immediately rejected.

The same holds true for the temptation to throw himself from the pinnacle of the temple. That suggestion, disguised in religious reasoning, was essentially a proposal to abandon trust in God and place himself in Satan’s hands. Jesus fully understood the idea — it had to be understood in order to be temptation — but it found no entry into his heart. The only response it produced was firm resistance and instant refusal.

This leads to an important clarification. Temptation, in its earliest and innocent stage, exists when the tempting object appears only at the level of thought — when it is intellectually perceived and recognized as temptation. If it stops there and never enters desire or will, there is no sin. It must begin in thought; otherwise, temptation wouldn’t exist at all. But the mere presence of the thought, without consent, is not sinful.

That said, thoughts that remain purely intellectual can still feel dangerous. For them to qualify as temptation, there must be a real possibility of further movement — a sense that the desire could follow. This awareness often brings an immediate inner alarm. The conscience, affections, and will are all alert, not passive. Even when no sinful desire arises, the soul senses the risk and instinctively recoils.

Second: Temptations That Touch Desire Without Becoming Sin

There is another category of temptation that works differently. In some situations, temptation does move beyond thought and awakens feeling — and yet does so without sin. This is because many desires are morally good in themselves. They become sinful only when they exceed proper limits.

In these cases, the tempting object is perceived intellectually, just as before. But it is also received into the affections and enjoyed at least to some degree. That degree matters deeply. Where the boundary lies depends on the situation, the nature of the desire, and the responsibilities of the person involved. That boundary can usually be identified through God’s commands, an enlightened conscience, the guidance of the Holy Spirit, or all three together.

For a holy person, temptation always stops at that boundary. When it reaches the point where desire would become excessive or disordered, it is checked. Just as in the first class of temptation, there is a conscious sense of danger near the limit, along with an active internal resistance.

One final clarification belongs here. There is an important difference between evil thoughts and thoughts of evil. Wandering or purposeless thoughts — especially those that could be redirected toward God’s glory but aren’t — carry some measure of moral wrong. But suggestions of evil that arise involuntarily, or are introduced from outside the self, are not sinful unless they are welcomed or acted upon. The key words are necessarily and involuntarily. If such thoughts are deliberately entertained or fostered so that a person becomes their author, they are no longer innocent.

These ideas, taken together, form a general outline of how temptation works. The subject has its complexities, but this framework helps make sense of it. What remains is to draw some practical conclusions.

Practical Reflections on Temptation

 

1. Everyone Is Tempted

No one is exempt from temptation — not even the most holy. Entirely Sanctified people still possess all the natural traits of human life. They hunger, grow tired, feel affection, experience grief, and even express anger, as Jesus himself did. Holiness does not remove human constitution; it brings it into harmony with God’s will. While it is possible to live free from known, voluntary sin, freedom from temptation itself does not belong to this life. Even Jesus, though sinless, “was tempted in all points as we are.”

2. Never Treat Temptation Lightly

It is dangerous to play with temptation or linger near it unnecessarily. Scripture commands us, “Stay awake and pray that you may not come into the time of trial” (Matthew 26:41 NRSV). Proverbs asks pointedly, “Can fire be carried in the bosom without burning one’s clothes?” (Proverbs 6:27, 28 NRSV). True obedience includes avoiding not just wrongdoing, but also the situations likely to lead there.

3. Resistance Can Make Temptation Fiercer

Ironically, temptation often grows more intense the more firmly it is resisted. Those who yield easily never experience the enemy’s full force. But the person who is resolved to obey completely — to sin not at all — will come to know how powerful temptation can be. Whenever someone advances into a new and clearer level of obedience, they should expect conflict there. Satan fiercely opposes holy ground.

4. Know Your Own Vulnerabilities

Understanding temptation is part of Christian duty — especially understanding how it personally affects us. What tempts one person may not affect another. Temptation always involves both the object and the individual. Wisdom requires us to study our weakest points and remain alert there.

5. When in Doubt, Wait

If we are uncertain whether a desire or action is rightful, the safest choice is to pause and seek God’s guidance. Acting without conviction is dangerous. As the apostle teaches, “whatever does not proceed from faith is sin.” (Romans 14:23 NRSV).

6. Stay Calm and Tranquil

Temptation becomes far more dangerous when it disturbs our inner peace. God is present in temptation — not as its source, but as its governor. He permits it for good purposes and will not allow it to go beyond what serves those ends. Remembering this helps keep the soul settled and submissive until the trial passes.

7. Faith Is the Great Defense

Faith is the primary weapon against temptation. In moments of danger, the prayer of faith rises instantly — “Protect me, O God, for in you I take refuge.” (Psalm 16:1 NRSV). This prayer is not only for desired help, but is, in itself, confident belief that help is given. God’s promises stand firm, and faith lays hold of them. Especially for those who live by faith daily, this prayer meets temptation almost as soon as it appears. It is simple, but powerful. It draws strength from the atoning blood of Christ, where the enemy’s fiery darts are quenched.

8. Grace Must Be Continually Renewed

Grace for one moment’s temptation does not guarantee strength for the next. Each day brings its own trials, and each requires fresh faith. Through repeated reliance on Christ’s sacrifice, we are both protected from present temptation and cleansed when we fall. 

Temptations, though painful for a time, are ultimately strengthening. They deepen faith and yield lasting righteousness. Even Christ himself “learned obedience through what he suffered.” (Hebrews 5:8 NRSV).

 

 

 

 

---

This is a revision of Part 1, Chapter 19 of Thomas C. Upham's book The Interior or Hidden Life (2nd edition 1844), written with the assistance of Microslop CoPilot. The original chapter can be found here: On the nature of the temptations of a Sanctified Heart.